#46 - JRL 2008-99 - JRL Home
Context (Moscow Times)
May 16-22, 2008
Death of a Journalist
A new documentary, "Letter to Anna," charts the life and death of the journalist
Anna Politkovskaya. It is unlikely to be released in Russia.
By Roland Elliott Brown
Swiss director Eric Bergkraut doesn't expect his latest film, "Letter to
Anna," to go down well in Russia, or even to make it into theaters. But in an
interview after the premiere of the feature-length version at the Hot Docs
International Film Festival in Toronto, he said he didn't want his film to be
perceived as "anti-Russian."
"One can be very critical of Mr. Putin's politics without being anti-Russian
at all," Bergkraut emphasized. "I am not sure if that is understood in Moscow
today."
"Letter to Anna" is a documentary describing the life and death of the
independent-minded Russian journalist Anna Politkovskaya, who was often treated
with suspicion by the Russian authorities, and indeed by no small number of
ordinary Russians.
Politkovskaya was best known for her critical writing on the wars in
Chechnya, which appeared in the Russian newspaper Novaya Gazeta, and in her
books, "A Dirty War," and "A Small Corner of Hell."
She was shot to death in the elevator of her Moscow apartment building on
October 7, 2006.
Bergkraut first met Politkovskaya in 2003, while he was working on his
documentary, "Coca: The Dove From Chechnya," a film about a Chechen woman who
had filmed human rights abuses in the republic.
Bergkraut asked Politkovskaya to appear in the film, and she agreed.
"My first impression of Anna was that she was very busy, very focused on her
work, and that she was afraid of wasting her time. But once we started talking,
we had very long talks, much longer than we had intended," Bergkraut said.
"What I liked was that she was always on the side of the weak person. I never
had the feeling that it was about good Chechens and bad Russians. She was not
naive at all. She just found the way the Russian government was dealing with the
conflict not very intelligent."
Bergkraut assembled "Letter to Anna" from footage of Politkovskaya left over
from "Coca," as well as footage which he shot in Russia after her death.
The film includes interviews with Politkovskaya's son Ilya, her daughter
Vera, her ex-husband, Alexander Politkovsky, and makes clear that
Politkovskaya's family feared for her life.
"Her family wanted to stop her. The only person who did not want to stop her
was her daughter, Vera, who had a deep understanding for what her mother did.
All the others -- and it's very understandable -- tried to stop her, but it was
not possible."
The idea of living in exile was impossible for her, he said. "She did not
want to leave the country. That would have been in total contradiction to who
she was and how she lived."
Expatriate Russian billionaire and Kremlin critic Boris Berezovsky is among
the Kremlin opponents Bergkraut interviews in the film, which is one reason he
expects to have difficulties getting it screened in Russia.
"The film could do without Berezovsky, but why should it? Why is it
impossible for Russians to see Berezovsky?" Bergkraut asked.
"He is a kind of Mephisto in the film. He is not the good guy. He has to be
in the film because, [Russian Prosecutor General] Yury Chaika said at a press
conference that [Politkovskaya's] murder could only have come from abroad, from
oligarchs. It is quite clear that he was pointing at Berezovsky," he said.
Another possible obstacle to the film's presentation in Russia might be
Politkovskaya's characterization of the war in Chechnya as "genocidal."
"She gives a very good argument," says Bergkraut. "Do you know how many
people have been killed in Chechnya? We do not know the figures. Maybe only
80,000. Maybe 150,000. Maybe 300,000. It's really a tragedy. Chechens are a very
small community," he said.
"But every single Russian soldier and his family is a tragedy too, for me.
It's not necessarily that I share [her] judgment, but I wanted to show it," he
added.
"Letter to Anna" also includes appearances by Garry Kasparov, Novaya Gazeta
editor Dmitry Muratov, and other colleagues and acquaintances of Politkovskaya.
Bergkraut regrets that he was not able to represent "official Russia" more
thoroughly in his film.
"I tried very hard to get an interview with Yury Chaika, but it was not
possible. I am trying hard to understand [his position]. I would have loved to
have more official Russian voices," he said.
Bergkraut also laments that no one from "official Russia" has attended any of
his international screenings.
"At all the screenings of my film, I was expecting that some day someone from
the Russian embassy would come, and we would have a discussion. Nobody ever
came. It's a pity. My last film has been shown in about 30 countries, but not in
Russia. Isn't that strange?"
After winning the International Human Rights Film Award for "Coca" in Berlin
last year, Bergkraut was approached by several film stars who expressed interest
in collaborating with him. As a result, Susan Sarandon, Catherine Deneuve, and
Iris Berben provided the narrations for "Letter to Anna" in its English, French,
and German versions, respectively.
Bergkraut's film was also honored by Vaclav Havel when it screened at the One
World International Human Rights Documentary Film Festival in Prague earlier
this year.
"Festivals and television stations are now approaching me because they want
to show "Letter to Anna," but no one has come to me from Russia," Bergkraut
said.
"A discussion [about Politkovskaya] -- which may be controversial -- would be
interesting and somehow natural. The best thing would be if a Russian television
channel bought "Letter to Anna. Maybe one day. Things can change."
|