#26 - JRL 2008-97 - JRL Home
RFE/RL
May 16, 2008
Analysis: Global Food Crisis Catches Up With Russia
By RFE/RL analyst Victor Yasmann
Copyright (c) 2008. RFE/RL, Inc. Reprinted with the permission of Radio Free
Europe/Radio Liberty, 1201 Connecticut Ave., N.W. Washington DC 20036.
www.rferl.org
Food prices will be the biggest single problem facing newly minted Russian
President Dmitry Medvedev. Over the last six months, hardly a single speech by
Medvedev, Vladimir Putin, or other leading Russian political figures has failed
to include mention of this burning issue.
And for good reason. Even as food prices rise dramatically around the world,
the rate of increase in Russia has been roughly three times greater than that in
the European Union. In April, the cost of basic foodstuffs rose in Russia by 6.4
percent, compared to 1.8 percent in Europe, according to official Russian
figures.
Depending on the region, prices of basic products such as bread, milk, and
meat have risen between 7 and 22 percent so far this year, moving inflation to
the top of the list of Russia's national concerns. An opinion survey in March
found that 39 percent of Russians view rising food prices as the biggest
national problem, while 38 percent named inflation generally, and 27 percent
named low wages. Just 8 percent of respondents mentioned corruption.
These findings are an early warning worth heeding in a country with a history
of hunger-triggered political unrest, most notably the 1917 February Revolution
that toppled Tsar Nicholas II. The Kremlin understands this and purchased a
measure of political stability during the election cycle that began last
December with three price freezes on basic consumer goods. Earlier this year,
Putin asked Deputy Prime Minister and Finance Minister Aleksei Kudrin (who
retained both posts after Putin moved to the premiership last week) to head a
special commission on inflation and to report weekly on the status of prices
across the country.
As the last price freeze expired on April 30, the government was preparing a
special "food-security" law that would indefinitely fix the prices of seven
"socially important" commodities.
Medvedev, who for the last three years has overseen an ambitious national
project to revive the agricultural sector, has tried to contain the political
damage that seems inevitable if prices surge following the expiry of the latest
price freeze. He has said that a global food deficit is the main driver of
Russia's food troubles, adding that if not for his efforts in recent years, the
situation would be worse.
"It is very regrettable when you work and work and then this rubbish comes
from the world market because of the mistakes of our colleagues in other
countries," Medvedev complained. "And as a result the entire planet is
suffering."
Leading Food Importer
Although food prices are, indeed, rising globally, Russia's leaders have
downplayed the fact that Russia is one of the world's leading importers of food.
As such, it stands to suffer disproportionately from the food crisis.
Among G8 countries, only Russia and Japan are net food importers. Russia
imports about 46 percent of the food and agricultural raw materials it consumes
each year. At a February 14 press conference, Putin revealed that some of
Russia's largest cities import up to 85 percent of the food they consume. All in
all, Russia imports 75 percent of the meat it consumes and half of the vegetable
oil.
Still worse, Russian dependence on imported food is on the rise. Food imports
increased by a factor of three between 2000 and 2006, and the primary reason for
this is the ongoing decline of the country's agricultural sector. To take just
one example, meat and milk production has fallen by half since 1990, and
Russia's total cattle herd has declined to the level of 1918.
Despite all of Moscow's talk of its "sovereign democracy," the country has
failed to boost its independence in this crucial arena.
According to figures released by the World Bank and the UN last month, global
price increases for food are likely to continue, and accelerate, for the next
decade. Russia's dependence on imported food has important domestic and
international implications. Not only is it possible that food-related social
unrest could disturb Russia's fragile stability, but it is also likely that the
costs of supporting this habit could derail the Kremlin's ambitious plans to
reshape the national economy.
The Kremlin will be forced to divert more and more of its petrodollar
windfall from national-development projects to the purchase of food imports. In
fact, this process has already begun, as the country is swept by a massive wave
of consumerism. Despite the price increases, Russia's consumption of meat, for
instance, has increased 5 percent in 2008 alone. To meet rising demand, Moscow
reduced import duties. Naturally, this boosted imports, but that made domestic
production less competitive and enraged Russian farmers.
Haves And Have-Nots
The food crisis is also exacerbating the gap between the haves and the
have-nots. While the richest part of the population can afford to spend more on
food and can even increase consumption, the poorest 20 percent -- those who
already spend about 60 percent of their income on food -- find themselves sorely
pressed.
On April 30, Agriculture Minister Aleksei Gordeyev (who likewise retains his
post under the new regime) proposed dealing with this situation by adopting a
so-called food-security law that would regulate prices of some commodities and
increase state subsidies to the agricultural sector several times over. It also
includes a provision that would introduce food stamps for the poorest Russians.
Gordeyev's proposal has met with skepticism by those who see it as a relic of
the Soviet planned economy and note that a similar plan was proposed by the
Communist Party in 1997.
Such a plan would likely have inflationary consequences and would do little
to resolve the food-production problem. Nevertheless, the Economic Development
and Trade Ministry has compiled a list of the socially important food products
that would be subject to price controls -- including bread, milk, vegetable oil,
butter, eggs, salt, and tea.
The good news for Russia is that the country has available land and water
resources to boost agricultural production. The bad news, however, is that this
cannot be done quickly enough to forestall the social, economic, and political
impact of its food deficit. The country simply lacks the workforce, the
infrastructure, and the financial mechanisms for rapid development in this
sector.
Russia's food problem also has an international dimension. In recent years,
Moscow -- as a major exporter of energy to the European Union and the countries
of the Commonwealth of Independent States -- has used its position of strength
for political ends, arguing that it is the seller, not the buyer, who determines
prices. Now Russia finds itself in the position of an importer of a vital
resource that cannot be replenished domestically any time soon. Russia, for
instance, imports 35 percent of its beef and 40 percent of its pork from the
European Union.
Because of the humanitarian nature of food supplies, it is unlikely the
Western democracies would openly use their leverage to pressure Moscow except in
a crisis situation. However, the Putin-Medvedev leadership is aware of Russia's
vulnerability on this point. In practical terms, this realization will serve as
a natural constraint on Moscow's assertiveness in both the near and far abroad.
|