#9 - JRL 2008-88 - JRL Home
Moscow Times
May 6, 2008
Stricter Rules for Press in Putin's White House
By Anatoly Medetsky / Staff Writer
Reporters have been allowed to wander around the White House as they pleased
for the past 16 years -- with the exception of the fifth-floor area around the
prime minister's office.
But the rules have changed in the weeks before Vladimir Putin moves in as
prime minister.
Reporters are now confined to a fifth-floor pressroom, where they wait for
one or more ministers to show up after Cabinet meetings every Thursday. The
reporters also can visit an improvised cafeteria down the hall for free tea,
coffee and sandwiches or the nearby bathroom.
A plainclothes Federal Guard Service officer keeps an eye on them, making
sure that they don't wander off too far. A White House press service employee is
on standby, ready to escort departing reporters to the ground-floor exit.
Asked what would happen if a reporter strayed away, a Cabinet spokeswoman in
the pressroom said, "You'd better not do that for your own safety."
The changes at the White House are not aimed a suppressing information but at
bringing its standards for reporters in line with those in the Kremlin, another
Cabinet spokeswoman said.
"These are the rules that Putin is used to in the Kremlin," said the
spokeswoman, who spoke on condition of anonymity because she wasn't authorized
to comment on the issue.
While the Kremlin has opened up under Putin by making a spokesman available
for comment at almost all hours, it has developed a reputation for keeping a
tight lid on all information and preventing leaks. The same kind of secrecy
could now shroud the Cabinet, leading to a lot of double-guessing about what is
going on, some reporters said.
"All this was done to control information rather than disseminate it," said
Vera Kuznetsova, who has written on Cabinet affairs for Vremya Novostei since
1999. "They want to put all journalists under their control."
The new rules, announced to Cabinet pool reporters when they accompanied
Prime Minister Viktor Zubkov to Slovakia on April 3 and 4, also canceled the
right of journalists from newswires and major newspapers to enter the White
House at any time between 9 a.m. and 6 p.m. Separate accreditation is now
required for every meeting or event that reporters want to attend.
The new rules have put a stronger filter on the flow of information, some
reporters complained. The short news conferences that Cabinet members give after
sessions are not enough to write in-depth stories about government decisions and
policies, Kuznetsova said.
Journalists still manage to meet senior sources such as deputy prime
ministers or their aides, but that requires not only their consent but also
permission from the press service, Kuznetsova said. A press officer escorts the
reporter to and from the meeting, she said.
At least one opportunity to meet high-placed officials vanished with the
tightening of the screws on reporters' movements, said Igor Naumov, who has
covered the Cabinet for Nezavisimaya Gazeta for the past four years.
When Cabinet ministers and lower-ranking officials walked out of the room
where they meet every Thursday, Naumov sometimes waited outside to catch a quick
comment, he said. In one case, he spoke with Vladimir Yakunin, chief of Russian
Railways, in an impromptu interview, he said.
"It was the norm. No one restrained us," he said. "Now we don't see these
officials."
Kuznetsova and Naumov said they did not abuse the rules by freely navigating
the building to pay unsolicited visits. "I am a well-bred person, and I don't go
where I am not invited," Kuznetsova said.
Another veteran reporter shrugged off the more stringent rules, saying he
would always find a way to contact his sources. He spoke on condition of
anonymity and declined to speak further on the subject.
Under Zubkov, the Cabinet previously took another step away from openness,
banning closed-circuit television broadcasts from Cabinet sessions in October.
Some of the most liberal rules for the media were in place when Viktor
Chernomyrdin was prime minister in the mid-1990s. Reporters were then allowed to
sit in on the weekly Cabinet meetings.
In what could be an effort to make up for the latest restrictions, the
Cabinet's press service has made a duty officer available from 8 a.m. to 8 p.m.
to answer reporters' questions. The duty officer's e-mail has the extension
aprf.ru, an acronym that stands for the Administration of the President of the
Russian Federation.
Kremlin spokesman Dmitry Peskov, who will become deputy chief of staff in
Putin's Cabinet, stood by the new rules, saying they would not hamper reporters'
work under Putin as prime minister. Putin is expected to be confirmed as prime
minister on Thursday, the day after Dmitry Medvedev is sworn in as president.
"Putin during his term as president demonstrated unprecedented openness with
the press," Peskov said. "This dialog and transparency will be continued."
Peskov's near round-the-clock availability as Kremlin spokesman has given
reporters unprecedented access to the Kremlin.
The new rules, Peskov said, simply brought the Cabinet's security up to that
of the offices of news organizations. "If I, as a press secretary, were to try
to walk into a newspaper's office, I would not be able to do that at any given
moment," he said.
Andrei Lapshov, who served as deputy chief of the Cabinet's press service
when Putin was prime minister in 1999, noted that reporters still had the
opportunity to meet their sources in cafes or on the street.
"There's no ban on officials talking to the media so far," said Lapshov,
president of the public relations company Insiders.
In addition, individual ministries remain as open as before, and reporters
can build more contacts and seek more information there, Lapshov said.
But he conceded that the new rules could lead to more wild guesses about the
Cabinet's plans. "Perhaps there will be more rumors," he said.
----------
Rules for Reporters
Reporters will face tougher restrictions under a Prime Minister Vladimir
Putin. Here is an overview of how they have fared under previous prime
ministers.
Viktor Chernomyrdin (1992 1998): Journalists allowed to sit in on Cabinet
meetings.
Sergei Kiriyenko (1998): Reporters' access to the Cabinet meeting room
restricted.
Yevgeny Primakov (1998 1999): Reporters barred from the Cabinet meeting
room, allowed only to watch broadcasts of speeches by individual ministers on
closed-circuit television.
Vladimir Putin (1999): Broadcasts on closed-circuit television limited to
opening remarks by prime minister. Briefings organized at the end of Cabinet
sessions to talk about Cabinet decisions.
Mikhail Fradkov (2004 2007): Broadcasts on closed-circuit television
expanded to include first two issues on the agenda of Cabinet meetings.
Ministers spoke to reporters in the pressroom or at briefings outside the
Cabinet meeting room.
Viktor Zubkov (2007 Present): Broadcasts limited to prime minister's
opening remarks. Ministers who deliver key speeches at Cabinet meetings talk to
reporters in the pressroom afterward.
-- Anatoly Medetsky
|