#6 - JRL 2008-78 - JRL Home
RFE/RL
April 15, 2008
Russia: The New And Improved Single-Party State
By Brian Whitmore
Copyright (c) 2008. RFE/RL, Inc. Reprinted with the permission of Radio Free
Europe/Radio Liberty, 1201 Connecticut Ave., N.W. Washington DC 20036.
www.rferl.org
In accepting an invitation to become the leader of Russia's ruling party,
outgoing President Vladimir Putin has not only secured a comfortable job for
himself after leaving the Kremlin. He's also set the stage for a potential
overhaul of the country's political system.
Putin announced his decision to lead Unified Russia during a speech on the
second and final day of the party's congress on April 15 in Moscow.
"Working efficiently together, the government and the parliamentary majority
make it possible to successfully develop the economy, improve health care and
education, raise incomes, and strengthen our country's defense," a
forceful-sounding Putin said, to thunderous applause. "I accept, with gratitude,
the proposal put forward by party members and its leadership."
Putin has already said he will serve as prime minister when he turns over the
presidency to his handpicked successor Dmitry Medvedev next month.
But analysts say it is the Kremlin leader's decision to become the head of
Unified Russia that could prove even more significant. The move gives Putin a
power base that should enable him to remain Russia's de facto ruler -- possibly
indefinitely, if he so chooses. This is because Unified Russia is more than just
a ruling party. It is the single reservoir of the country's political, business,
and bureaucratic elite.
Holding The Reins
In an interview with RFE/RL, Olga Kryshtanovskaya, head of the Institute for
Elite Studies at the Russian Academy of Sciences, says that leading Unified
Russia gives Putin control over most of the country's political establishment.
"He'll have the State Duma as a resource, since Unified Russia has a majority
there," Kryshtanovskaya says. "He will have control over the Federation Council,
where they also have a majority. He will have control over regional parliaments,
because there they have a majority as well. These regional parliaments confirm
the governors. His administrative resources will increase significantly."
Analysts say the emerging arrangement is beginning to resemble the Soviet
system, in which actual power resided with the Communist Party, and high state
posts -- like the president, prime minister, or leader of parliament -- were
largely ceremonial. The general secretary of the Communist Party was the
country's true ruler.
Kryshtanovskaya says the system has been "substantially modernized" to
accommodate a market economy, and contains window dressing like carefully
managed multicandidate and multiparty elections that give the appearance of
plurality but ultimately keep power within the central party.
In essence, she says, Russia's evolving political system is taking nearly all
its cues from the USSR. "This process can be called Sovietization in the most
general sense," Kryshtanovskaya says. "Many mechanisms of the state machine are
beginning to resemble Soviet ones. This includes the process of leadership
recruitment, which will go through Unified Russia."
Advantage, Putin
Putin's move also means that he will remain personally dominant in Russian
politics even after Medvedev moves into the Kremlin.
Analysts have been divided over whether as prime minister Putin would be able
to maintain control over Russia's political system and sprawling bureaucracy,
given the enormous constitutional power Medvedev will enjoy as president.
(Medvedev this week declined an invitation to join Unified Russia, saying such a
move would be "premature.")
Lilia Shevtsova, co-chairwoman of the Russian domestic politics and political
institutions project at the Moscow Carnegie Center, tells RFE/RL's Russian
Service that Putin is now gaining political "weight and muscle" as he prepares
for his post-Kremlin career.
"Imagine President Medvedev without a party, or as a rank and file member of
the party, or even a member of its leadership," Shevtsova says. "But the leader
of that party is Putin. Therefore in this tango for two, the disproportions will
increase [in Putin's favor]. This will weaken the position not only of the
president, but the presidency itself."
Shevtsova describes Unified Russia as being "like a glove on Putin's hand"
throughout his presidency. It was formed in 2001 -- largely as a vehicle to
support Putin's policies -- when the pro-Kremlin party Unity merged with Moscow
Mayor Yury Luzhkov's Fatherland-All Russia.
Party Purge?
There had been some speculation about whether Unified Russia's dominance
would continue after his presidential term ended.
Stanislav Belkovsky, a political analyst who heads the Moscow-based Institute
for National Strategy, tells RFE/RL's Russian Service that before Putin's ascent
to the party leadership, top members of Unified Russia had been increasingly
fearful of losing their privileges under the incoming regime.
"Unified Russia is not a party in the classical political understanding of
that term. Unified Russia is a club of bureaucrats and businessmen who have one
aim: access to the Kremlin trough," Belkovsky says. "Boris Gryzlov, the formal
leader of Unified Russia, [deputy Kremlin chief of staff] Vladislav Surkov, and
their comrades are very frightened that President Dmitry Medvedev will exclude
them from the trough."
The new developments, of course, mean that that will most likely not happen.
Shevtsova says having Putin at the helm gives the party "a second wind."
But in his acceptance speech, Putin indicated that his leadership comes with
strings attached. The party, it seems, can expect changes in the near future --
possibly in the form of a Soviet-style purge.
"The party, as I have already said many times, should be reformed," Putin
said. "Essentially, this is exactly what we're witnessing now. It must be more
open to discussion, taking into account the views of the voters. It must be rid
of bureaucracy, cleared of random people pursuing solely their personal goals
and benefits."
|