#41 - JRL 2008-71 - JRL Home
RFE/RL
April 8, 2008
Russia: Ex-Kremlin Journalist Talks From U.K. Asylum
By Chloe Arnold
Copyright (c) 2008. RFE/RL, Inc. Reprinted with the permission of Radio Free
Europe/Radio Liberty, 1201 Connecticut Ave., N.W. Washington DC 20036.
www.rferl.org
Five years ago, she was the talk of the Russian publishing world: a sassy
young reporter unafraid of spilling the beans about what really goes on behind
the walls of the Kremlin.
Today, Yelena Tregubova lives in a secret location in the United Kingdom,
where she fled after her writing made her many new enemies.
It's been just a week since her asylum application was accepted, and the
former "Kommersant" reporter has been told not to reveal her address -- even to
her family in Russia.
"I feel huge relief, as you can imagine, because for a year I was living with
this massive uncertainty" as U.K. authorities processed her asylum request,
Tregubova says. "That's to say I hoped against hope, but couldn't be 100 percent
sure, that it would be approved. The British government could just have decided
to wash their hands of this matter, they could just have said, 'Why would we
want to get involved with this journalist and her problems? Let's just keep on
good terms with the Kremlin and forget about her asylum application.'"
Tregubova's asylum victory comes at a critical time in British-Russian
relations. Some say the relationship is at its most strained since the Cold War.
Russia has refused to extradite the man wanted in Britain for the murder of
Aleksandr Litvinenko -- a former security service agent-turned-British citizen,
who was poisoned in London in 2006.
Russia, in turn, accuses Britain of harboring wanted men, including business
tycoon Boris Berezovsky, a vocal critic of the Kremlin, and Chechen separatists,
including Akhmed Zakayev.
Both Russia and Britain have expelled diplomats. More recently, the British
Council has been forced to close its doors in Russia. Last month, Russia's
Federal Security Service (FSB) raided the Moscow offices of the British oil
major BP.
'Kremlin Digger'
For Tregubova, however, Britain has become a refuge, and her home for the
foreseeable future.
"I think that while the current regime is in power -- the one created by
[Vladimir] Putin, as the [former] head of the secret services -- I won't be able
to return to Russia," she says. "The door is closed for me, because I would be
in mortal danger [if I went back]."
Tregubova's troubles began after the publication in 2003 of her hugely
successful "Tales Of A Kremlin Digger," a book that dished the dirt on life in
the Kremlin. There is the story of an intimate lunch with Putin, then head of
the FSB, at a sushi bar in downtown Moscow. "I couldn't tell whether he was
trying to recruit me, or chat me up," she writes.
Tregubova recounts the bungling attempts of factory bosses to impress the
president on regional tours, and presidential blunders that his PR men try to
cover up.
But as sales of the book skyrocketed, Tregubova lost her job, was thrown out
of the Kremlin reporters pool, and started to receive death threats. An
explosion went off outside her door that she says was certainly intended to kill
her. Then, a year ago, she got another threat.
"I was abroad at the time, and I got information [that] I would be in mortal
danger if I returned to my homeland," she says. "Of course, I knew that there
was a difference between bravery and suicide. I'm not a kamikaze."
She confesses that "frankly, I didn't think that when my book was published
these nasty goings-on would go so far. Who would have thought that people would
go to such lengths for revenge?"
Journalist Deaths
An alarming number of journalists in Russia have learned the hard way just
how strong the opposition to their work can be. Since Putin came to power in
2000, more than a dozen journalists have been killed in contract killings -- the
most recent occurring just last month, and the most sensational being the
slaying of investigative reporter Anna Politkovskaya in 1996.
Forty-seven journalists have been killed in the line of duty since 1992,
according to the international Committee To Protect Journalists (CPJ), while
reports of beatings and intimidation are common.
Often enough, the government plays a prominent role in the pressures faced by
the media.
Natalya Morar, a correspondent for the weekly "Novoye vremya" who has
Moldovan citizenship, was barred last month from entering Russia for a second
time. She was prevented from entering Russia in December on national-security
grounds after writing articles about alleged corruption within the Kremlin.
And as of April 7, accredited journalists have been barred from open access
to the Russian White House, the main government office complex in Moscow. All
official press communications will be distributed by fax and e-mail and
published on the government's official website, ending the need for journalists
to physically enter the building except for official events.
Tregubova says she despairs of the current state of the media in Russia.
"It's probably not very ethical for me, sitting so far away, in a civilized
European country, where human rights are guaranteed, where freedom of speech and
freedom of the press are taken for granted -- it wouldn't be ethical for me to
criticize those colleagues of mine still in my homeland," Tregubova says. "But
frankly, I think that what's going on there is less like journalism than some
sort of harem."
The New 'Samizdat'
She says even the boldest of her Kremlin-reporter friends have been reduced
to writing flattering anecdotes about the president. No one dares to criticize
or write anything different today, she says, because they fear the consequences.
As for television, she says, it has become a "nightmare similar to what was
shown in Communist Party leader Leonid Brezhnev's era." Russia's three main
television channels are either state-controlled or owned by Kremlin-friendly
enterprises, which means you never see news that's critical of the government,
Tregubova says.
What is interesting, she says, is that samizdat -- the illicit reports
published during the Soviet era that were critical of the regime -- have started
to reappear, but in a different format.
"In fact, the strange thing today is that the Internet is playing the role of
publisher of samizdat," Tregubova says. "I think that the future journalism
textbooks will reflect this. Have a look, for example, at the grani.ru website
-- content-wise it is human rights-oriented per se. In fact, this is just what
existed before -- underground 'chronicle of the current events' or chronicle of
what was going on during the pre-reform times in the Soviet Union."
Recently alarms have been raised that the government -- after becoming wary
of modern methods of disseminating information -- has stepped up efforts to
monitor and control electronic communications and the Internet. In addressing a
recent Internet forum, President-elect Dmitry Medvedev reportedly told the
audience that the government must consider "the delicate question of the
relationship between freedom of speech and responsibility."
"I'm afraid that the Russian media must go through the very same difficult
path it went through [at the collapse of the Soviet Union]," Tregubova says.
"Just as when Yeltsin's reforms began, we built journalism with our own hands,
we started a new style, we tried to study western journalism -- so the next
generation will have to do the same thing in 10, 15 years' time, when the
current regime has gone."
Today, Tregubova is writing another book about her experiences. It keeps her
busy, she says, and stops her thinking about the things she misses about Russia:
"so many things, it's too painful to talk about them."
But what she doesn't miss is the way that the country is run today.
"I just think it's very sad that the history of reform in Russia, the attempt
at liberalization -- it's all over. This great historical opportunity has been
lost," Tregubova says. "Russia has gone back to being a colony for former KGB
agents, who've changed in name only -- a fuel-rich colony for a small group of
oil and gas merchants who give nothing of their riches to anyone living outside
the capital."
|