#29 - JRL 2008-64 - JRL Home
Russia Profile
March 26, 2008
The New “Caucasian Captive”
The Informational Picture Painted in the Blogosphere Is Different From the
Official One
Comment by Georgy Bovt
Lately the Russian mass media – both traditional and Internet – has more and
more frequently broached the subject of “regulating the Internet” -- whether it
is possible, and if so, by what means. And, most importantly, how far the
authorities are willing go in their attempts to isolate themselves from the
outside world for the sake of their own political peace. Fortunately for them,
there are examples of such regulation in the practice of very different
countries around the world. In Iran, for example, in addition to constant strict
censorship (political as well as aesthetic, moral and religious), the
authorities made a large-scale attempt to temporarily block the Internet as a
whole, during the recent parliamentary election. In Cuba, the only “mere
mortals” that have access (and limited access at that) to the Internet are
doctors. In China, the art of regulating the Internet has reached such “heights”
that the authorities have learned not only to constantly monitor the
“suspicious” and the “shady,” but also to efficiently react to the changing
political and international situation. Thus, during the recent upheaval in Tibet
the authorities were rather effective in blocking the inflow of all kinds of
unwanted information. As soon as it turned out that the popular YouTube website
can serve as a source of revolt, the authorities blocked access to it throughout
China’s territory.
So far, all talk of regulating the Internet in Russia concentrates on morals,
as well as on the need to somehow limit “extremism.” But while “immorality” is
associated mostly with pedophilia, “extremism” might take on diverse
definitions, since according to the recently passed legislation any harsh
statements toward representatives of authorities of all levels can be considered
“extremism.” The first criminal case of this type was taken to court not so long
ago – a case against a blogger from Syktyvkar who addressed obscenities to
police officers and urged for them to be burned at the stake. His appeal was
taken literally, particularly as sedition and “promoting violence.”
A little while ago “Internet theorists” discussed whether it will be possible
for Internet blogs and other “small” resources to become news sources for
traditional mass media. Today, this has already happened in Russia. The Russian
Internet is actively creating its own informational reality, one that not only
lives its own life, different from the official one, but also periodically
throws insolent challenges at the official reality.
The official Russian mass media discuss new cleansing campaigns against the
“werewolf officers,” and the authorities become preoccupied with raising the
prestige of law enforcement. The Russian Internet replies by distributing a
collection of photographs from the everyday life of simple Russian police
officers, taken with a hidden camera; the impressions made by these images are
able to outweigh the propagandist tension of all the most zealous speeches, made
at the topmost levels. And the Internet collection makes it obvious that at the
common, “philistine” level, the image of an average Russian police officer is
basically “unsalvageable.”
Thus the Russian blogosphere is becoming bolder; it is starting to form its
own alternative informational picture, different from the official one. That is,
it is becoming politically dangerous. Especially since today, the Russian
Internet includes more than 20 million active users, and almost 3.5 million
blogs (up by 2.6 million from last year). More than 75 percent of all
Russian-language journals are maintained by five web hosting services:
LiveJournal.com, LiveInternet.ru, Diary.ru, Blogs@Mail.ru and LovePlanet.ru.
Physically, the largest number of online diaries is on LiveInternet, but it is
also the host of the smallest number of regularly updated journals – not more
than 20 percent. The most “alive” hosting service is LiveJournal. According to
some estimations, about 40 percent of its blogs are very active. It should also
be considered the one to boast most socially significant and political topics.
This is probably what the company SUP had in mind when it purchased the rights
for servicing the Cyrillic sector of LiveJournal: it is the only blog hosting
service today that can brag to have men as the majority of its users (almost 60
percent), with the average user’s age being 25 (which is the most attractive age
group for advertisers). LiveJournal hosts a few of the most popular Internet
communities. At that, every day more than 7000 new blogs and about 210 000 new
posts appear in the Russian Internet.
The Russian Internet, or its unofficial portion, to be exact, called “the
blogosphere”, actively celebrated Dmitry Medvedev’s presidential campaign and
election victory. Thus, the only episode from the televised election debates
that became popular among bloggers was the one of Vladimir Zhirinovsky nearly
beating up candidate Andrei Bogdanov’s representative. If it wasn’t for this
brawl, most Russian bloggers would have probably never found out about the fact
that the debates ever took place.
Medvedev’s victory was celebrated with a number of friendly and not so
friendly jokes and cartoons. The most popular item was probably a video created
from the renowned Soviet movie “The Caucasian Captive”: the authors recorded new
sound for the restaurant episode, where an experienced and cynical Caucasian man
talks the naïve, young Shurik, who just came from Moscow for his summer
vacation, into participating in the “bride kidnapping custom,” supposedly as
part of studying Caucasian ethnography, but actually to marry her off to a local
Communist party boss. So, in the newly recorded version of the episode, the
naïve Shurik is turned into Dima, and the characters are talking about a
“make-belief” presidential election. It seems like this video was spread to
nearly all the Russian Internet users in just 24 hours. By the way, the topic of
Medvedev’s “lack of independence” from Putin is one of the most popular topics
in the Russian blogosphere.
It is not surprising that the idea of starting to regulate the Russian
Internet is practically hanging in the Russian political atmosphere. It is not
only a matter of intentional intimidation of the Internet community by
demonstrative criminal cases against individual bloggers charged with
“extremism” (to make sure others don’t do the same ting), but also of direct
regulation. For example, there was recently a law draft that suggested licensing
for all blogs with more than 1000 visits per day (thus making the blogs equal to
regular mass media). Due to the technical mistakes made in the draft, it was
turned down; however, the regulation idea itself is still alive and well. The
logic of development of the authorities’ attitude toward mass media leads to
dealing with the Internet at least according to the “Chinese model,” unless this
development will not be suddenly turned around under the new Russian president.
So far I, personally, am skeptical about the prospects of such a “warming.” If
only because Dmitry Medvedev, unlike Vladimir Putin, has always paid a lot of
attention to the Internet and has never underestimated it.
|