#25 - JRL 2008-46 - JRL Home
RFE/RL
March 1, 2008
Russia: NTV's Past Points Toward REN-TV's Future
By RFE/RL analyst Robert Coalson
Copyright (c) 2008. RFE/RL, Inc. Reprinted with the permission of Radio Free
Europe/Radio Liberty, 1201 Connecticut Ave., N.W. Washington DC 20036.
www.rferl.org
When independent experts this week released their assessment of media
coverage of the Russian presidential election, there were few surprises. On
Channel One, First Deputy Prime Minister Dmitry Medvedev got 32 percent of
election-related airtime; on Rossia, he got 26 percent; on TV-Tsentr, he got 35
percent; and on NTV he got 43 percent.
The other three official candidates all got single-digit coverage on all four
national networks, with figures ranging from 6.8 percent to 0.1 percent,
according to figures released by the Center for Journalism in Extreme
Situations. Also unsurprisingly, President Vladimir Putin -- who isn't running,
of course -- got more airtime even than Medvedev, ranging around 50-60 percent.
The one oddity in this bland picture, however, was REN-TV, a small, but
still-private national network. REN-TV's figures are truly startling: 31 percent
of the airtime went to Putin, followed by 21 percent for Medvedev, 22 percent
for Liberal Democratic Party of Russia head Vladimir Zhirinovsky, 21 percent to
Communist candidate Gennady Zyuganov, and 6.3 percent to Democratic Party head
Andrei Bogdanov.
Such even-handedness is unheard of in Russian national media these days. The
reduced percentage to Bogdanov can easily be justified by the facts that his
support consistently polls at about 1 percent, that his party received less than
1 percent of the vote in the December Duma elections, and that his candidacy is
widely seen to be a Kremlin-inspired stratagem to create the impression that at
least one liberal politician is in the race.
The contrast between REN-TV and NTV is particularly noteworthy. NTV, it
should be recalled, is the once-private and once-respected national television
network that was taken over by Gazprom in 2000-01 as one of the first major
steps in Putin's dismantling of civil society. At the time, Gazprom claimed the
takeover was merely a business dispute and senior managers pledged endlessly the
network would be sold off in short order.
Now, seven years later, Medvedev is the chairman of Gazprom's board of
directors and that channel is outdoing even the formally state-controlled
Channel One and Rossia in violating the law ensuring equal media access to all
candidates and in contributing to what the liberal-posing Medvedev has
eloquently described as "legal nihilism."
In an interview with "Kommersant" on February 21, Gazprom-media head Nikolai
Senkevich said that Medvedev pays personal attention to this part of the vast
conglomerate's empire and confirmed that close Medvedev allies from St.
Petersburg -- Anton Ivanov, Mikhail Krotov, and Konstantin Chuichenko -- have
worked in the media holding (although Ivanov and Krotov have since moved into
high positions in government). Senkevich said Gazprom-Media "has the warmest
memories and greatest gratitude" for the work Medvedev and his associates did
for the holding.
In 2000, NTV was the odd man out on the Russian media scene. Now, REN-TV is.
And its future doesn't look bright.
REN-TV is a network of 864 stations across Russia, the Commonwealth of
Independent States, and the Baltic states. As of December 2006, 51 percent of
its shares are held by a company called Arbos, while 30 percent are held by the
Luxemburg-based RTL Group, part of the Bertelsmann media conglomerate. Arbos
also controls 35 percent of the Peterburg television company, which runs the St.
Petersburg-based Channel Five. Channel Five, it should be noted, was granted
federal status by Putin in November 2007, opening the way for massive expansion.
Arbos is part of a complex corporate chain at the top of which sits Yury
Kovalchuk, co-owner of the Rossia bank and a close personal friend of President
Putin. Kovalchuk's bank came to prominence during the 1990s by handling most of
the finances for the St. Petersburg municipal external-relations committee,
which was then headed by Putin. Journalists and analysts over the years have
repeatedly claimed that Kovalchuk is Putin's personal banker, managing a fortune
that some have estimated is worth billions of dollars. Arbos, it is worth
noting, also owns a major stake in a company called Sogaz, which is major owner
of a company called Lider, which in turn manages Gazfond -- the huge pension
fund of Gazprom. Sogaz also owns 10 percent of the Peterburg television company.
Kovalchuk's media ambitions extend much further. All the major newspapers in
St. Petersburg -- "Smena," "Nevskoye vremya," "Vecherneye vremya," and "Vecherny
Peterburg" -- are also considered part of his group, as they are controlled by
long-time business ally Oleg Rudnov. Rudnov's media projects have been financed
by Gazprom, which is the major advertiser of all of his newspapers. In addition,
Gazprom-Media head Senkevich confirmed in his "Kommersant" interview that a deal
has been struck (but not implemented) to sell control of the national daily
"Izvestia" to Sogaz, which would place it inside Kovalchuk's media empire as
well.
In a recent report summing up the results of Putin's eight years in power,
former Deputy Prime Minister Boris Nemtsov and former Deputy Energy Minister
Vladimir Milov drew particular attention to Kovalchuk's emerging media empire.
They describe it as a "powerful political resource," potentially more
influential than anything ever controlled by former oligarchs Vladimir Gusinsky
or Boris Berezovsky.
According to "Moskovsky korrespondent" on February 15, Kovalchuk plans to
combine his media holdings into a single company called the National Media
Group, a name that reflects his ambitions. According to the report, the new
holding company will be headed by Sergei Fursenko, the brother of Science and
Education Minister Andrei Fursenko. Reportedly, Kovalchuk has been friends with
both Fursenko brothers since grade school. The same report asserts that Lyubov
Sovershayeva, a former deputy presidential envoy to the Northwest Federal
District, sits on the boards of directors of both REN-TV and the Peterburg
television company.
"Gazeta" reported earlier this month that Kovalchuk has created a new public
advisory board to oversee REN-TV. The board will most likely eventually oversee
the entire National Media Group. The board will include well-known cultural
figures, artists, politicians, and businesspeople, the daily reported, and will
be headed by Unified Russia Duma Deputy and former rhythmic gymnast Alina
Kabayeva. Kabayeva is also believed to be a friend of Putin's.
What this all means for REN-TV's admirably even-handed election coverage
remains to be seen. But political analyst Dmitry Oreshkin is skeptical: "The
channel will become controlled and managed," he told "Gazeta." "Everything will
happen gradually, just as it did with NTV."
|