#18 - JRL 2008-154 - JRL Home
International Relations and Security Network (ISN)
ISN Security Watch
[receives funding from the Swiss government]
http://www.isn.ethz.ch
August 21, 2008
Letters from Georgia: Nationalism and fear
People fleeing to Tbilisi arrive by the truckload into an atmosphere filled with
apprehension and nationalism.
By Ben Judah in Tbilisi for ISN Security Watch
Ben Judah is a senior correspondent for ISN Security Watch. He is based in
London and Paris.
Children are playing outside Tbilisi's School Six but they are not taking a
break from their studies. Inside the dilapidated classrooms almost 400
internally displaced persons (IDP) from South Ossetia and Gori are unpacking the
few belongings they have brought from rubbish sacks and plastic bags. Georgian
sources estimate that as many as 60,000 such IDPs are now in the capital.
Dali Dzarcemi points out his village on a map of Georgia hanging above a
blackboard. "A week ago Russians, Ossetians, Chechens and Cossacks came and
burned our house," he told me. "All of the Georgian people living in the village
had to flee.
"I don't think I will be able to go back to my village. It's in the area the
Ossetians want to keep. I'm terrified. I'm a farmer. I have no clue how I can
make a good life for me and my family in the city," he told me.
Dzarcemi said his wife's brother was shot during the fighting and is in the
hospital, but he is mostly concerned about his two year old son Sergo.
"We are not hungry. We have what we need. But the special stuff you need for
children is expensive and they don't give it for free. My wife is pregnant, how
can I raise a newborn and a small boy in a classroom with two rubbish bags of
possessions?"
In the next classroom along the corridor Achiko Yelkcenuli worries about his
brother in the army. "I haven't heard from him today. Normally he calls every
day. You never know if something could have happened."
Achiko says he has lost his home and knows dozens of people who have either
lost family members or friends. I ask him if those who fled the fighting blame
Georgian President Mikhail Saakashvili in any way for the conflict, which began
when he ordered a military incursion into South Ossetia on 7 August, prompting
Russia's fierce response.
"No. I am a proud Georgian. I am proud of my leader. He is defending our land
against the enemy."
There are similar replies from others in the center; and often nationalist
claims that the Ossetians only arrived in thet 1920s, on the back of Russian
troops who invaded the area.
The school's director, Shota Manjavidze, has hastily become the man in charge
of the group. When I ask him about their feelings toward the Georgian
government, I get a more nuanced reply. "There are people who don't like
Saakashvili here in this center: I think half of them. But they keep quiet about
it. It's best not to be heard speaking against him. It's not patriotic. People
could get very angry about that."
As I make my way to the Georgian state television center I pass three
military truckloads of people who fled the fighting. One of the passgeners, Dato,
is from Gori and has just finished studying at the Georgian Technical
University. When I asked him for his opinion of the government, he said that it
had tried to bring Georgia into the European and NATO fold, and was almost
successful.
"But this war is not about that – Russia can have on its borders only slaves
or enemies. She could not have a free and successful Georgia."
Dato's views are a reflection of how Georgians themselves are interpreting
the war – not as an opening clash between former president and now prime
minister Vladimir Putin's resurgent Russia and the West in a second Cold War -
but as a national struggle for land and independence.
Walls around Tbilisi are covered with nationalist graffiti and the press here
is full of patriotic photos of Georgian soldiers holding holy icons. For most
people I speak to, the EU and NATO are dream-like concepts while the real story
is about reclaiming territory they view as having been stolen from them by
Russian-backed separatists.
Dato argues that Saakashvili is the right leader at the right time. "The Rose
Revolution was about national pride. He personifies that. When I see how the
whole world is with him during this war it makes me proud to be Georgian – and
certain that somehow we will win."
Inside the buildings the Georgian state television center I meet Tamar
Urushadze, a young reporter who says she was shot four times by Russian troops
live on air. Her arm is bandaged and hangs in a sling. She says will never have
full use of it again.
For Urushadze these are frightening times. "There is fear. Nobody really
knows what will happen to our country and our people. Right now people are
rallying around the flag and the government. Even the opposition parties are
behind Saakashvili now. This is about our survival as a free and sovereign
state."
The atmosphere in Tbilisi is one of nationalism and fear as more people
continue to arrive from South Ossetia. There is uncertainty over what will
unfold, which only only deepens the conflict narrative sold by the government
and taken up by most of the population: a national struggle against a barbaric
enemy to defend the inviolable borders of the state. European peacemakers and
Georgia's ally, the US, should consider this as they attempt to bring not just a
cease-fire to Georgia – but also a lasting solution to its woes.
|