#15 - JRL 2007-99 - JRL Home
Russia Profile
www.russiaprofile.org
The Holy Touch
By Andrei Zolotov, Jr.
The last contribution that Boris Yeltsin made to building a new Russia was
that he inadvertently gave the country a new ritual of state funeral. What we
all saw on Wednesday was an important step in the formation of a new canon.
Future leaders may introduce some changes to it, but the precedent and the frame
of reference are now set.
No longer will Russian leaders lay in state at the Hall of Columns of the
House of the [Trade] Unions – Moscow’s former Nobility Assembly, where Lenin’s
body was first displayed in 1924 and where all subsequent Soviet leaders lay in
state. And no longer will they be buried near Lenin’s Mausoleum in Red Square –
in the necropolis of the Soviet elite whose future is at present being debated.
Instead, on Wednesday the whole world watched the solemn beauty of the
Orthodox Christian burial service, with CNN and BBC commentators using epithets
like “grandiose” and “majestic” to describe the proceedings. Everybody has
pointed to the fact that the funeral service was taking place in the Christ the
Savior Cathedral, which was rebuilt under Boris Yeltsin as a symbol of the
extraordinary revival of Russia and the Orthodox Church after the demise of the
Communist era.
Similarly to Yeltsin’s own life and rule, the reconstruction of the cathedral
was a controversial venture, and far from everyone was happy with it. But today
it stands as a monument to our recent history and the desperate attempts to
reconnect, however inconsistently, with our non-Soviet past.
“Boris Nikolayevich’s fate reflected the dramatic history of the 20th
century,” Patriarch Alexy II wrote in a message read out in the cathedral before
the service. Yeltsin felt “the people’s will for a free life” and helped to make
it happen, the patriarch wrote, recalling Yeltsin’s kind treatment of the
Russian Orthodox Church and his own personal relationship with the former
president. “For the first time in more than 100 years, we are sending off the
head of the Russian state in a church, with prayer,” he wrote.
Yet, despite their long-standing personal relationship, Patriarch Alexy chose
not to interrupt his treatment in Switzerland to give Yeltsin the last blessing.
The fact that the head of the Russian Orthodox Church goes several times a year
to an unidentified Swiss clinic is never publicly announced, but it is widely
known in church circles. He telephoned Yeltsin’s widow, Naina, and sent two
official messages. But the funeral itself was led instead by three senior
bishops: Metropolitan Yuvenaly, who presided and read the patriarch’s message,
and Metropolitans Kirill and Kliment, who are both seen as potential successors
to the patriarch.
It is hard to say whether the reason behind the patriarch’s absence was just
his state of health and the importance of the ongoing treatment after the
exhausting Lenten and Easter services and ahead of the historical reconciliation
with the Russian Orthodox Church Abroad scheduled for May 17. Perhaps. But the
fact remains that the head of the Russian Orthodox Church was away at a
historical moment, when the eyes of the whole world were fixed on his church. Or
maybe this decision added a subtle detail to the ritual being formed today –
that a funeral conducted personally by the sitting head of the church is
reserved only for the royals and possibly a head of state who died in office,
not in retirement?
Much has been said about the monarchist instincts of most Russians and the
authoritarian character of Yeltsin’s 1993 constitution, which made the Russian
presidency more powerful than Tsar Nicholas II was after 1905. Yeltsin himself
was rumored to refer to himself as Tsar Boris and was depicted as such by many
cartoonists. Interestingly, this monarchist tendency was delicately reflected in
the service, too.
While thousands of Russians filed past the casket to pay their respects, the
Book of Psalms was read overnight, as befits laymen, over Yeltsin’s coffin by
Moscow seminarians – and not the Gospels, as tradition prescribes for priests
and the emperor.
But in a layman’s funeral service broadcast worldwide on Wednesday (the last
rites for clergy are different), the priests prayed not “for the repose of the
soul of Boris, the servant of God,” which would be the case in an ordinary
funeral, but, using a formula that sounded odd to the ears of Orthodox
Christians, for the “first President of Russia Boris Nikolayevich.” I don’t know
if those who prepared the service were thinking about it, but the use of the
patronymic form of the name in Russian Orthodox liturgy used to be reserved
solely for royalty. That’s how the emperor and his immediate family were
commemorated in the liturgy before the revolution – by their name and
patronymic. It has never been done since then.
The honor guard and the gun carriage recalled the past funerals of Soviet
leaders. But the site was not Red Square, but Novodevichy Cemetery – the
country’s most esteemed place of internment, where Nikita Khrushchev was buried
in near secrecy in 1971, seven years after he was ousted from the country’s top
post. Priests, family members and the sitting president followed the carriage,
not Politburo members. And the carriage itself was draped not in Communist red,
but in the white-blue-red tricolor of present-day Russia. It was a new ritual,
yet a very organic one.
Watching Yeltsin’s funeral, I recalled the only time I saw Boris Nikolayevich
up close, at the Cathedral of Christ the Savior on Easter in 1996. It was Easter
Vespers, a short festive service in the evening on Easter Sunday, which that
year fell on April 14, and was the first service conducted on the main floor of
the cathedral just two years after its reconstruction had begun.
The walls were already up, but none of the decorations were in place. Carpets
were placed on concrete floors and, amid the immense grey walls and iron rods
sticking out, the continuous chant of “Christ is Risen! – Indeed He is Risen!”
sounded with particular joy.
For me, it was also the day of my engagement. As my wife-to-be and I were
leaving the church, the bodyguards were making way for a giant man with a heap
of white hair. He was indeed a head taller than the crowd around him. “Look,
Yeltsin!” I told my bride. She couldn’t believe it.
Much has changed in Russia since then – for better and for worse. The
cathedral’s interior, reconstructed according to the old designs, shines today
with marble, paintings and gilded decor. Two empty thrones are the latest
addition – for the tsar and tsarina. And in the middle of it stood the coffin
with Yeltsin’s body, covered by the traditional shroud depicting Golgotha and
the Russian national flag, brought back by Yeltsin in 1991. The choir intoned
“Christ is Risen!” and “Memory Eternal!” Eternal indeed!
|