#25 - JRL 2007-88 - JRL Home
Chechnya: New Republic Head Moves To Consolidate Power
By Liz Fuller
Copyright (c) 2007. RFE/RL, Inc. Reprinted with the permission of Radio Free
Europe/Radio Liberty, 1201 Connecticut Ave., N.W. Washington DC 20036.
www.rferl.org
April 13, 2007 (RFE/RL) -- Following his lavish inauguration as Chechen
Republic head on April 5, Ramzan Kadyrov has moved to strengthen even further
his control over the Chechen government, naming one close relative as prime
minister and promoting to the post of first deputy prime minister a second
relative, Adam Delimkhanov, hitherto deputy prime minister responsible for
security and law and order.
On April 10, Kadyrov named as Chechnya's new prime minister his cousin, First
Deputy Prime Minister Odes Baysultanov, whom he had singled out one month
earlier as the most qualified candidate for that post. On April 10, Kadyrov
praised Baysultanov's role over the past year in expediting the reconstruction
of a major cement plant and Grozny airport.
And the daily "Kommersant" on April 11 quoted an aide to Alu Alkhanov,
Kadyrov's predecessor as republic head, as describing Baysultanov as not merely
a first-rate manager who succeeded in speeding up the reconstruction process,
but as devoid of any personal political ambitions.
In one respect, however, the choice of Baysultanov may prove controversial
and even counterproductive: he is a member of a "teyp" (clan) from southwestern
Chechnya, some of whose members have acquired a reputation for dishonesty and
theft. If Baysultanov comes to be perceived as similarly rapacious, his actions
could undermine the support base Kadyrov has built up over the past 12-18 months
by his efforts to expedite reconstruction and attract investment into Chechnya's
economy.
Alternatively, Kadyrov's opponents in Chechnya and elsewhere in Russia could
launch a slander campaign, accusing Baysultanov of embezzlement in order to
tarnish Kadyrov in the knowledge that such allegations would fall on fertile
ground.
Known For Brutality
In the weeks after Alu Alkhanov finally capitulated after a two-year standoff
with Kadyrov and stepped down in mid-February, and Russian President Vladimir
Putin proposed Kadyrov to succeed him as republic head, both Russian and Western
media have speculated at length on the reasons for Putin's apparent total
confidence in Kadyrov's ability to "normalize" the situation in Chechnya, and on
the extent of Kadyrov's loyalty to Moscow.
In the course of that debate, some Russian observers registered concern over
the possible consequences of handing absolute power to a man many consider at
best uncouth and unbalanced, and at worst an uneducated and sadistic psychopath.
Specifically, those observers question whether Kadyrov will succeed in forging a
similarly mutually beneficial relationship with whoever succeeds Putin as
Russian president one year from now.
True, as enumerated in the Chechen Constitution adopted in 2003, Kadyrov's
powers are no more extensive than those of the heads of other federation
subjects. (That may change, however, in light of plans to amend the Chechen
Constitution.)
But none of his peers have Kadyrov's reputation for condoning, if not
actually engaging in, abduction, torture, and murder. (In early March, one North
Caucasus website quoted a victim who claimed to have been tortured by Kadyrov
with a blowtorch). None has been branded a sadist or psychopath. None is known
to extort routinely a percentage of all salaries paid to public-sector
employees. Nor are they as lacking as Kadyrov in practical administrative
experience.
Going Too Far?
What's more, even Tatar President Mintimer Shaimiyev, who for over a decade
engaged in horse trading with successive Russian leaders in an attempt to secure
the maximum degree of autonomy and autarky for his republic, tacitly
acknowledged that there are limits which it is neither wise nor advisable to
ignore.
Kadyrov, by contrast, has over the past three years repeatedly been given to
understand that he stands to all intents and purposes above the law, insofar as
in Putin's eyes he can do no wrong: that in Dostoyevsky's memorable phrase
"everything is allowed." Given Kadyrov's known proclivities, that may prove to
have been ill-advised: it is not generally a terribly good idea to present a
certified pyromaniac with a state-of-the-art flamethrower.
This is not to say that at least some senior Russian officials do not have
qualms about Kadyrov's long-term agenda, specifically the possibility that he
may at some future date seek either greater autonomy or even independence for
Chechnya.
Speaking at Kadyrov's inauguration ceremony in Gudermes on April 5,
presidential envoy to the Southern Federal District Dmitry Kozak warned that
Chechens' collective aspirations to a better life can be realized only within
the parameters of the laws and constitution of the Russian Federation, a clear
allusion to the hypothesis floated by commentator Sergei Markedonov in early
March that Kadyrov either harbors a secret separatist agenda, or that he may
seek to blackmail Putin's successor by demanding ever-increasing economic
subsidies as the price for Chechnya remaining a part of the Russian Federation.
Broader Power Struggle
There are indications, however, that Kadyrov may have already decided on the
first step towards augmenting his power and influence -- by launching a campaign
to have neighboring Ingushetia again joined with Chechnya to form a single
republic. Kadyrov's close associate Dukvakha Abdurakhmanov, chairman of the
lower chamber of the Chechen parliament, proposed such a merger last summer,
even though Ingushetian President Murat Zyazikov has consistently argued against
it.
Zyazikov was present both at the consultations in Grozny on February 21 at
which Kozak selected Kadyrov as one of three possible candidates as republic
head, and at the March 2 parliament session that confirmed him in that post.
Immediately after that vote, Kadyrov personally chauffeured Kozak and Zyazikov
to Nazran, where they spoke to journalists. Although both Zyazikov and Kadyrov
stressed the cordial relations between their respective republics, Zyazikov's
entire demeanor and body language signaled defeat and acute distress, the most
probable explanation for his evident discomfort being that he is aware that his
days as president may be numbered.
The Chechen leadership's apparent decision not to push any longer for a draft
power-sharing treaty between the federal center and the Chechen Republic, but to
demand instead a free economic zone on Chechen territory, may likewise be part
of a longer-term broader strategy under which the Chechen Republic in its
current borders and with its current name may soon be a thing of the past.
Despite his reputation for tolerating corruption and his near-zero popularity
among the population of Ingushetia, Zyazikov has been regarded until now as
unsinkable, given that both he and Putin are veterans of the Federal Security
Service (FSB). Zyazikov requested, and obtained, a formal expression of approval
from Putin in the summer of 2005.
The question thus arises: is Putin so assured of his future postpresidential
role that he could afford to risk alienating his former FSB colleagues by
publicly sacrificing Zyazikov at this juncture? Or will Putin leave it to his
successor to decide on both Zyazikov's removal and the abolition of Ingushetia
as a full-fledged subject of the Russian Federation?
|