#40 - JRL 2007-165 - JRL Home
Beslan Mothers Say New Video Refutes Official Version
Copyright (c) 2007. RFE/RL, Inc. Reprinted with the permission of Radio Free
Europe/Radio Liberty, 1201 Connecticut Ave., N.W. Washington DC 20036.
www.rferl.org
July 30, 2007 (RFE/RL) -- Relatives of the more than 330 victims of the
Beslan school siege have released a video that they say proves Russian security
forces caused the massacre by firing grenades on the besieged building.
Many of the relatives of those killed at the bloody school siege in
September, 2004, have never believed the official version of events.
An initial inquiry concluded that the fiery conclusion to the crisis was
caused by explosions inside the school hall, where Chechen separatists had held
more than 1,000 people, most of them children, hostage for three days.
Now a video posted anonymously and linked to the Beslan Mothers Committee
website appears to show that the explosions came from outside the building,
where Russian special forces were preparing to storm the school on the third
day.
Over 330 victims, more than half of them children, were killed in the siege,
which ended in chaos when security forces stormed the sports hall to free the
children and parents.
Beslan Mothers
Aneta Gadiyeva, a member of the Beslan Mothers Committee who lost her
daughter in the massacre, says the video supports her theory that security
forces fired two grenade rounds on the school gymnasium, starting a fire that
then engulfed the building.
She told RFE/RL that the committee is appealing to investigators to watch the
video: "We are once again appealing to the authorities to make this tape
available to investigators, although in fact they had this tape, but they did
not take it into consideration. For some reason they decided not to include this
tape [in the investigation]."
Marina Litvinovich, the editor of the Truth about Beslan website, told RFE/RL
the video refutes the official version of events.
"[This tape] confirms the original version of the events that unfolded in the
Beslan school on September 3: that the explosions came not from the
hostage-takers within the hall, but that the school was targeted by machine-gun
fire and grenades from outside the hall," Litvinovich said.
Booby Traps
In the video, children are seen running from the building before two loud
blasts are heard -- apparently from outside the sports hall. But last year, the
official commission into the Beslan tragedy vindicated the security forces and
said that the explosions were caused by the hostage-takers, who set off booby
traps.
Families of those killed in the school siege are still waiting for
investigators to deliver a final report on the tragedy. But they say the video
they have received supports their theory that there has been an official
cover-up.
An independent report by explosives expert Yury Savelyev alleged that Russian
security forces were responsible for two explosions that triggered the storming
of the school.
Sergei Markedonov, a political analyst at the Institute for Political and
Military Analysis and an expert on the Caucasus region, said he can't understand
why the authorities have not taken some responsibility for what happened.
"I think that unfortunately September 1 will forever be associated with the
events of Beslan, and it seems to me that there are some serious lessons to be
learned from this. It seems to me that the head of the Russian government could
participate more fully in the events of Beslan," Markedonov said.
The only hostage-taker officials say survived the siege, Nurpashi Kulayev,
was jailed last year for life for his part in the siege.
(RFE/RL's North Caucasus and Russian services contributed to this report.
With additional material from Reuters.)
|