#16 - JRL 2007-142 - JRL Home
Jamestown Foundation
www.Jamestown.org
Eurasia Daily Monitor
Volume 4, Number 125
June 27, 2007
KREMLIN REJECTS "FOREIGN" APPROACH TO RUSSIAN HISTORY
By Pavel Felgenhauer
Last week President Vladimir Putin met with a selected group of delegates
attending a Kremlin-organized conference, "Timely Issues in Teaching Modern
History and Social Science." Putin told the teachers: "Many school books are
written by people who work to get foreign grants. They dance to the polka that
others have paid for. You understand? These books, regrettably, get into schools
and universities." Putin demanded new history textbooks that "make our citizens,
especially the young, proud of their country" and reiterated "no one must be
allowed to impose the feeling of guilt on us."
Putin pledged to hand out government grants to authors who will write proper
new textbooks. Following his recent pattern, he used the meeting to again lash
out at the United States. "Yes, we had terrible pages in Russia's history," he
said. "Let us recall the events since 1937, and let us not forget that. But in
other countries [the U.S.], it has been said, it was more terrible." Putin
suggested that Washington's use of nuclear weapons against Japan at the end of
World War II was worse than Stalin's political repression and mass murder. Putin
also cited the U.S. bombing campaign and use the defoliant Agent Orange during
the Vietnam War (official transcript, www.kremlin.ru, June 21).
The teachers' delegation dutifully rallied to Putin's patriotic call. Leonid
Polyakov, chair of the department of political science at the Higher School of
Economics and author of a new, officially approved textbook, announced that his
colleges have undertaken the task to create a "national-patriotic ideology."
These principles will help teachers in the "civic-patriotic education" of
students as a supplement to "traditional military-patriotic education."
Polyakov implied that Russia did not lose the Cold War, but instead
"voluntarily disarmed" and imported a "shaky, abstract ideology of universal
values, of words 'freedom,' 'democracy,' 'market,' 'human rights,' and 'civil
society'." According to Putin, this foreign ideology has created a "mishmash" in
Russian heads and in Russian society that must be corrected. Later, speaking on
a Russian First Channel talk show Sunday, June 24, Polyakov argued that the
invasion of Afghanistan by Russian troops in 1979 was neither a crime nor a
mistake, but a Cold War decision in Russia's interest, taken after due diligence
by the Kremlin.
Polyakov graduated from university in 1973 as a Marxist philosopher and
teacher of Marxist-Leninist Social Science. Putin graduated from university two
years later, already recruited to become a KGB spy. Polyakov told Putin that
today he is a happy man after being called upon to write a new textbook, that
his life efforts, experience, and education are once again needed and that
social science is back in the curriculum.
In Moscow during communist rule, it was often said that Russia is a nation
with an unpredictable past. History was written one way and then repeatedly
rewritten again. After the collapse of the USSR in 1991, it seemed for a time
that the writing of textbooks and history in general would be freed of strict
state control. Of course, historians, teachers, and journalists had been trained
during the communist-era, but in a relatively free country new methodologies,
untainted by totalitarianism, could rise -- but freedom did not last in Russia.
Putin specifically noted that the history of World War II and Russia's
history after 1991 are wrongly interpreted and must be rewritten. Today Stalin
has again been rehabilitated as a leader who made mistakes, but still secured
victory over Nazi Germany. The 1990s -- a decade when Russia was a freer state
than at anytime before or since -- today is demonized. The pro-Kremlin youth
movement Molodaya Gvardia has announced it will be organizing marches in
Yekaterinburg and other cities in support of Putin and against the regime's
critics under the slogan, "No return to the 1990s" (RIA-Novosti, June 26).
Maybe even more important than the rewriting of history, is that Putin once
again in unequivocal terms spelled out that he considers any Russian citizen or
organization that receives any grants or other financial support from abroad in
any form to be a paid agent of foreign interests -- a traitor. The traitors
dance a "polka" ordered by the enemies of Russia. In fact, Putin said it was a
"butterfly polka" (polka-babochka) -- a dance few perform or know anything
about. The expression itself is totally alien to modern Russian ears. It is an
expression from the Stalinist era that Putin perhaps remembered from long ago,
and it is a notion of total paranoia and xenophobia, minted during a time when
anti-Americanism was the cornerstone of "military-patriotic education."
Putin's personal paranoia and anti-Americanism seem to be growing and are
increasingly dominating external and internal Russian politics. This does not
mean that Russia is indeed reverting to communist totalitarianism. Putin is not
a "Commie," but a strictly observant Orthodox Christian, which is almost as
demanding as being a strictly observant Orthodox Jew. It apparently was Putin's
explicit Christian observance that fooled George W. Bush at their first meeting
in 2001 into seeing a reclusive Kremlin dictator as a potential close ally. That
was a total illusion, since many in the hierarchy of the Russian Orthodox Church
tend to be as anti-Western, anti-American, xenophobic, and just as paranoid as
are Russian Communists, the military, and the former KGB.
|