#5 - JRL 2007-111 - JRL Home
Moscow Times
May 16, 2007
Russia, EU Scramble to Save Summit
By Anna Smolchenko
Staff Writer
NOVO-OGARYOVO, Moscow Region -- The most pressing issue ahead of Friday's
Russia-EU summit is not Russian gas, Polish meat or an Estonian statue but that
the summit will take place as scheduled, Russian officials said.
German Foreign Minister Frank-Walter Steinmeier did not offer much hope after
holding two hours of talks at Putin's Novo-Ogaryovo residence outside Moscow.
"Preparing for the summit has been difficult," Steinmeier told reporters
through an interpreter. "There have been a number of specific problems that we
have not been able to solve over the past few weeks. Keeping silent about them
doesn't help."
He added, "Today, we are seeing the situation much clearer."
The minister did not provide further details in his brief remarks and left
promptly afterward.
Putin conceded problems at the start of the meeting but sought to minimize
them, saying: "Thank God, there is not conflict of interest between Russia and
the EU. We have different views on how to solve problems, but there is a desire
on both sides to solve these problems. That's not a bad start."
The Kremlin said maintaining a regular dialog with the EU was important, and
it is throwing out all the stops to make sure that the biannual summit takes
place, with or without any agreements.
"There's no point in digging around for a scoop," said Kremlin spokesman
Dmitry Peskov. "Indeed, the summit is unlikely to bring about any breakthroughs.
But it is valuable as it is."
Sergei Ryabkov, a senior Foreign Ministry official helping organize the
summit, said the meeting did not need to bring concrete results and the mere
fact that it was held would be an achievement of sorts.
"Such high-level contacts are moving relations forward," he said.
He said the Kremlin's recent sharp rhetoric was nothing new for EU diplomats,
who had heard the same complaints in private talks earlier. After the quiet
diplomacy failed, "We are raising the decibels to get heard," Ryabkov said.
He downplayed talk of a crisis in relations. "Difficult doesn't mean crisis,"
he said.
Tuesday's last-minute talks, initiated by Germany, which holds the EU
presidency, began with a one-hour meeting among Steinmeier, Putin, Foreign
Minister Sergei Lavrov, Kremlin foreign policy adviser Sergei Prikhodko,
Agriculture Minister Alexei Gordeyev and Putin's adviser on EU affairs, Sergei
Yastrzhembsky. Steinmeier then spoke for an hour alone with Putin, a German
Embassy official said.
Lavrov and Prikhodko stepped outside during that hour, with Lavrov taking the
opportunity to have a smoke. Meanwhile, two black Mercedes sedans kept their
engines running in case Steinmeier would emerge. But he kept deferring his exit
in an apparent attempt to reach a compromise.
The embassy official, who asked not to be identified because he was not
authorized to comment, said he doubted that any breakthrough had been reached
and predicted that "there will be less and less substance" at the summit and
beyond in Russian-EU relations.
"It looks like the Cold War in the sense that you don't know what to expect"
from the Russia side, the official said.
In a sign of the summit's importance for Russia, authorities on Friday
unexpectedly gave permission for an opposition Dissenters' March to be held in
Samara on the day of the summit, which will take place in a nearby Volga River
resort. The decision reversed an earlier ban and came amid EU prodding.
Ties with the EU worsened earlier this month during Russia's dispute with
Estonia over the relocation of a Soviet war memorial. Relations were already
strained over EU worries about the reliability of Russian gas supplies, a
dispute about flyover rights for EU airlines, and Russia's refusal to support
effective independence for Kosovo.
Moscow and Brussels need to start talks on a new framework agreement that
covers trade, energy and foreign policy. But Poland blocked the start of the
negotiations at the last Russia-EU summit in Helsinki in November and has said
it will do so again Friday if Russia does not lift a ban on Polish meat imports.
The tensions look bad, but the summit's cancellation would amount to an
outright scandal, said Masha Lipman, a political analyst with the Carnegie
Moscow Center. "As contacts are becoming more and more shallow, the main purpose
will be to maintain decorum," she said.
Friday's talks will be easier for Russia than for the deeply divided EU, and
Germany will be hard-pressed to find a solution that would suit all 27 EU
members, said Andrei Klimov, who is in charge of EU relations on the State
Duma's International Affairs Committee.
Citing private talks with Western diplomats and lawmakers, Klimov said West
European officials often fume that former communist countries like Poland,
Estonia and Lithuania were throwing a wrench into the works of formulating the
EU's common policy.
"They are just seeking to elevate their status within the EU," Klimov said.
Even so, Russia should have realized earlier that the EU would rather side
with an errant member state than agree with Russia, said Nikolai Kaveshnikov, a
research fellow with the Institute of Europe in the Russian Academy of Sciences.
"They may be sons of bitches, but they are our sons of bitches," Kaveshnikov
said of the EU's philosophy.
Informal talks will start when German Chancellor Angela Merkel and Putin
arrive at the resort of Volzhsky Utyos on Thursday evening, said Ryabkov, the
Foreign Ministry official. The actual summit is on Friday.
Although officials said there was no written agenda, two major sets of
questions will be discussed. Russia and the EU will first delve into bilateral
relations and then move on to international issues including Kosovo, Iran and
Iraq, Ryabkov said.
A total of 100 delegates, 50 from each side, will gather at the Soviet-era
resort, owned by the Presidential Property Department. About 500 reporters are
expected to cover the talks.
The resort has been fixed up and is ready to host the guests, Kremlin
officials said. "Everything is gleaming here," a Kremlin spokeswoman for the
summit said by telephone from Samara.
Some 700 million to 800 million rubles ($27 million to $31 million) have been
spent since last fall to give the resort a facelift, said Viktor Khrekov, a
property department spokesman.
The Kremlin would not say how much money the summit would end up costing
Russia, which is picking up the tab. The next summit is scheduled for Lisbon in
October.
|