#18 - JRL 2006-124 - JRL Home
RFE/RL
June 2, 2006
Russia: 'Phallic' Case Threatens Internet Freedom
By Brian Whitmore
Copyright (c) 2006. RFE/RL, Inc. Reprinted with the permission of Radio Free
Europe/Radio Liberty, 1201 Connecticut Ave., N.W. Washington DC 20036.
www.rferl.org
When Russian prosecutors opened a criminal case against journalist Vladimir
Rakhmanov for writing a satirical Internet article calling President Vladimir
Putin the nation's "phallic symbol," it raised eyebrows. But a case that began
as an odd curiosity in Russia's Ivanovo Oblast is quickly becoming an
international cause. Reporters Without Borders has taken up Rakhmankov's case as
part of what it calls a campaign to preserve Internet press freedom in Russia
and elsewhere in the former Soviet Union. With print and broadcast journalism
already subject to heavy-handed state control, free-press advocates are
increasingly looking to save the Internet as the region's last censorship-free
zone.
PRAGUE, June 2, 2006 (RFE/RL) -- Rakhmankov's article comparing Putin to a
phallic symbol wasn't the first time the online journalist has irritated the
authorities.
In March, he accused Ivanovo Governor Mikhail Men of taking bribes. In an
interview with RFE/RL's Russian Service, Rakhmankov said the official response
was violent.
Violent Past
"I was invited to the Ivanovo Oblast government press service," Rakhmankov
said. "I was met there not by the press secretary or by other employees of the
press service, but by a security guard. He didn't say one word. He just started
to beat me. He punched me three times in the stomach, then he screamed at me and
asked who ordered the article."
Back in 2002, Rakhmankov received another beating, over an article that got a
local police chief fired for corruption.
But when Rakhmankov wrote an article last month parodying Putin's appeal to
reverse Russia's demographic decline, Ivanovo authorities tried another tactic
-- shutting down his website (cursiv.ru), searching his apartment, and
confiscating his computers.
Local prosecutors have also charged Rakhmankov with "insulting a
representative of the state." He is under house arrest and he could face up to a
year of hard labor if found guilty.
The whole matter might have ended there with little outside intervention. But
the Paris-based watchdog group Reporters Without Borders saw in Rakhmankov's
case an opportunity to make a stand for press freedom in Russia.
Last Refuge
Increasingly, free-press advocates see the Internet as the last
censorship-free haven in Russia.
"The only way to publish independent information in this country is to use
the Internet," explained Julien Pain, head of the Internet Freedom Bureau of
Reporters Without Borders. "That is why this case is so important. When the
Russian authorities have the same control over the Internet as they have over
traditional media then I think Russia will be in real trouble."
Last year, Reporters Without Borders published a report identifying 15
so-called "Internet black holes" -- countries where the Internet faces the
harshest restrictions.
Three former Soviet states made the list -- Belarus, Uzbekistan, and
Turkmenistan.
By comparison, the Internet is still relatively free in Russia. But according
to Pain, that could be about to change.
"Belarus, Uzbekistan, Turkmenistan -- all these countries filter the Internet
extensively," Pain said. "And so far in Russia the Internet is quite free. And
we have to admit, that's because Russian authorities so far haven't dedicated
too much effort on controlling the Internet. But this is about to change, and
that is why we have to talk about it now."
Russian lawmakers have been discussing ways to control Internet content for
years.
Climat Of Fear
But even in the absence of legislation, authorities can still use what
Reporters Without Borders called a "climate of fear" to intimidate hosting
companies and Internet service providers.
Rakhmankov's site, for example, was shut down not by the authorities but by
the hosting company, which claimed that he had not paid his bills -- even though
the site was hosted free of charge.
Speaking on the RFE/RL Russia Service program "Press Time" on May 24,
attorney Vladimir Entin, one of the authors of Russia's media law, defended the
authorities' prosecution of Rakhmankov.
"The head of state is a subject of national pride, in the same way that the
flag and the coat of arms and other symbols of the state are, and requires
similar respectful relations," Entin said.
But speaking on the same program, Rakhmankov retorted that the president has
no special right to be sheltered from insult. He added that if the case must be
prosecuted, it should be subject to civil litigation rather than criminal law.
"I think that in this case, it is not right to distinguish the head of state
from an ordinary citizen," Rakhmankov said. "And I do not agree that the
president is a symbol, like the flag or the coat of arms. And insofar as people
have their own opinions about where the line is between insults and irony, such
a thing needs to be investigated under the provisions in civil law for the
defense of one's honor and dignity."
No trial date has yet been set for Rakhmankov's trial. Investigators,
meanwhile, have hired a so-called "linguistic expert" to assess the gravity of
the insult to President Putin.
|