|
Did Reagan End the Cold War?
~ #37
By
Alan F. Kay, PhD
© 2004, (fair use with attribution and copy to author)
June 21, 2004 |
|
A Heritage
Foundation editorial widely printed shortly after June 6, among other things,
made a case that the American people believed President Ronald Reagan's efforts
ended the Cold War. Highly reliable polling data gives a different picture.
Two surveys were conducted by an ATI team on the topic of what ended the Cold
War. (See "Locating Consensus for Democracy", ATI 1998, p. 67).
President George H.W. Bush's pollster, Fred Steeper, who approved all questions,
was an ATI team member.
In March 1988, when
the Intermediate Nuclear Forces (INF) Treaty was in the Senate for approval, the
public in the first survey was asked to choose which of three developments was
the main reason that Soviet President Mikhail Gorbachev and other Soviet leaders
were ready to end the Cold War. The question found, ranked in order of
decreasing support, 34% of the public chose (1) "The Soviet economy is so
weak that they need to reduce their military spending," 34% of the
public chose (2) "Soviet leaders really want to reduce the risk of war," and
28% of the public chose (3) "President Reagan's military build-up forced
them to the bargaining table." Only 4% made no choice.
To help generate
taxpayer willingness to shell out a total of over a trillion dollars for the
military during the Cold War, our leaders' rhetoric from President Harry S.
Truman to Reagan held to the theme that the Soviets continued to grow ever more
powerful and threatening from 1947 to 1988. After 1988, with the Cold War
rapidly ending, the U.S. media changed its tune and produced a barrage of
stories of growing Soviet economic weaknesses. The first Bush administration,
heirs to Reagan, no doubt hoped that the public was coming around to a consensus
that it was the Reagan military build-up that brought the victory.
But the opposite
happened. Four years after the first survey, in 1992, the same question was
asked again by the same polling team. The percentages of the public that
thought the Soviets were ready to end the Cold war as a result of (1) economic
collapse grew from 34% to 63%, (2) the desire of the Soviet
leaders to really reduce the risk of war dropped from 34% to 16%,
and (3) the Reagan military build-up forcing the Soviets to the bargaining
table, had no increase at all, in fact a drop in half, from 28% to 14%.
Heritage Foundation, the people were just not with you on this one.
As for the
possibility that the public has come around to that belief more recently, I
think the media blitz-week, "All Reagan, all the time," of which the Heritage
Foundation editorial was a part, has not changed the public's view very much on
what ended the Cold War. Studies have shown that opinions on old developments,
significant at the time enough to be remembered by most people, change very
little over later years. (Loc. cit., pp 65-66)
o - o - o - o - o - o - o - o
Alan F. Kay is a mathematician, social scientist and pioneer of public-interest polling. He has authored
Locating Consensus for Democracy and numerous public policy articles and holds several patents. (see
www.publicinterestpolling.com)
|